The Pelican Bay advent calendar · Open on December 19
Nobody Under the Mistletoe
The mistletoe for the party scene is gone from the prop table, in the middle of the dress rehearsal of A Christmas Carol in the village hall. On stage were Wendell the Ferris wheel operator as Scrooge, Otto the baker as Marley's ghost, Mabel the museum guide, who directs, and Gus the lifeguard, who plays every other part. The call sheet says which row of the stage each of them was in. Each of them also says where in that row they stood, and one of them is not telling the truth. Who took the mistletoe?
Nobody Under the Mistletoe
Front
Who is lying?
Who is the culprit?
Pick one of the suspects you placed.
About this case
Nobody Under the Mistletoe is a Head Detective case from Pelican Bay: a 4×4 grid with 4 suspects. Dress rehearsal, and the mistletoe is gone. The call sheet tells the truth. One of the four does not.
Head Detective cases teach: one witness is lying.
Where to start: Assume one witness is the liar and see if the rest still fit. Only one choice works.
Stuck? Read how to play