Head Detective
The Lighthouse Mystery
Someone's been up in the old lighthouse after hours, and this morning the lamp was flashing an off pattern, throwing off boats coming into the bay. Four people admit they were there: Priya, Otto, Mabel, and Delia. The keeper's logbook confirms which landing each was on, but their statements about where on that landing don't all add up. One of them is lying. But who did it?
The Lighthouse Mystery
STAIRS
Who is lying?
Who is the culprit?
Pick one of the suspects you placed.
About this case
The Lighthouse Mystery is a Head Detective case from Pelican Bay: a 4×4 grid with 4 suspects. Four suspects. One is lying. Can you spot who?
Head Detective cases teach: one witness is lying.
Where to start: Assume one witness is the liar and see if the rest still fit. Only one choice works.
Stuck? Read how to play
Guides that help with this case
- How to solve a logic puzzle where one witness is lying
- How a whodunit logic puzzle is made (and checked)
- Knights and knaves puzzles explained (and how liar whodunits differ)

